Stan Martin
Apply Common Sense To Indemnity Claim
July 28th, 2015
A mechanical sub’s employee is severely injured during a coffee break when an improperly-fastened section of limestone façade comes loose near where he is sitting. Should the mechanical sub owe a duty of indemnity to the prime contractor? The Mass…
Read More
Read More
Right To Challenge Arbitration Award Cannot Be Waived By Contract
July 20th, 2015
A subcontract arbitration clause states that the parties may take steps to confirm an arbitration award, but agree not to challenge any award. A Georgia appellate court has held that the restriction on challenging an award impinges on the Georgia Arb…
Read More
Read More
Closing Out An Arbitration Award (How Not To)
July 1st, 2015
Two contractors concluded arbitration proceedings and the panel issued its award in February 2011. Upon request of one party, the panel amended its award to address outstanding liens, in March 2011. The amended award required certain lien waivers to…
Read More
Read More
Overbroad Indemnity Is Still Enforceable Within Statutory Limits
June 23rd, 2015
Oregon has a law, similar to many other states, prohibiting overbroad indemnities in construction contracts. The Oregon Supreme Court has ruled that the law allows an arguably overbroad indemnity to be enforced within the statutory constraints, rathe…
Read More
Read More
Senate Bill Would Transfer VA Project Oversight to Corps
June 19th, 2015
The Hill reports that an amendment to the Senate defense bill would transfer oversight of any U.S. Dept. of Veterans Affairs construction project larger than $100 million to the Army Corps of Engineers. The amendment is reportedly sponsored by the Co…
Read More
Read More
State Supreme Court Orders Official To Set Prevailing Wage Rates
June 17th, 2015
The New Mexico Supreme Court has ordered a public official to establish prevailing wage rates in accordance with current collective bargaining agreements. In what appears to have been a show-down among the legislative and executive branches, the cour…
Read More
Read More
Categories: Construction
Criticize the Contractor? An Arbitration Award for Defamation
June 10th, 2015
Hell hath no fury like a homeowner scorned, particularly one with access to sophisticated IT professionals who will establish and optimize a website solely to criticize the contractor. But the cabinetry contractor – whose arbitration award includin…
Read More
Read More
Mind The (Procedural) Gap – Third-Party Claims Lost
June 3rd, 2015
Owner sued contractor, who filed third-party claims against subs seeking only indemnity from them if the contractor was found liable to the owner. Contractor then moved to dismiss the owner’s claim as barred by the statute of limitations. The court…
Read More
Read More
Agreement for Specific Performance Precludes Actual Damages Claim
May 28th, 2015
In settling an environmental contamination claim, the property owner agreed to accept a cash payment and the environmental company agreed to perform remediation work. The settlement documents provided that the owner’s remedy was in specific perform…
Read More
Read More
Categories: Construction
Subcontract Is Enforceable Even Though Too Low To Pay Prevailing Wage Rates
May 22nd, 2015
A subcontractor agreed to perform site clearing work for $5,000, and only later learned it was a public project requiring payment of prevailing wages. Instead of paying workers $13 and $14 per hour, the sub would have to pay $36 and $43 for a chainsa…
Read More
Read More
Categories: Construction